Skip to content
emi.me

A story. Fiction, with real arithmetic.

The Wedding That Took Five Years to Pay For

The rule was one hundred and twenty guests. Nobody broke it. They only added one name at a time, each with a reason nobody could answer, until there were 450.

emi.me Editorial8 min read

60months

of instalments for three days of celebration. The borrowing itself cost ₹2,80,651.

This story is fictional. The financial calculations are based on stated assumptions.

  • Fiction: the story
  • Computed: the receipts
  • Verified: the blue notes

The list

Eleven weeks before

The list began as a single sheet torn from Arko’s exercise book, and one rule, which Subir Bhattacharya announced at the kitchen table in the voice he kept for announcing rules. One hundred and twenty people. Family and the lane. Not one more.

Mitali wrote the names. Subir kept the count in the margin, in pencil, like the accounts clerk he was. By nine o’clock they were at a hundred and eighteen and feeling rather good about themselves.

Then his mother, who was eighty-one and had been shelling peas without appearing to listen, said, “And Bulu’s family?”

Bulu was Thakuma’s late sister’s son, in Bardhaman. Bulu’s family was eleven people.

“We have not seen Bulu since the flood,” said Subir.

“He came for your father’s shraddha. He carried the bananas.”

You cannot argue with bananas. Bulu’s family went on the list. And because Bulu was coming, the Bardhaman cousins who were closer than Bulu had to come too, or it would look like a statement. Then the printing press: Subir had attended the weddings of four colleagues’ children, and eaten at every one. Then the groom’s side sent word, with great delicacy, that they would be about a hundred and forty. “Only the near ones.”

Each name arrived with a reason attached, and each reason was unanswerable on its own. That is how it works. Nobody at that table ever decided to invite 450 people. They decided, one name at a time, not to insult anyone.

Mohona, the bride, came home from the school where she taught, looked at the sheets (there were four by then), and said the thing she would remember later.

“Baba, can we afford this?”

“It is handled,” said Subir.

It is handled

He handled it at Saptarang Bank on a Tuesday, in his lunch hour. The young man at the desk was quick and pleasant and called him uncle. ₹8,00,000, five years, 13% fixed. The instalment would be ₹18,202.

Subir had totalled other people’s columns for thirty-one years. He looked at the one figure he had asked for, and not at the page of figures stapled behind it.

The wedding was magnificent. This has to be said plainly, because everything after it in this story is arithmetic and it would be easy to forget. Three days. A gate of marigolds. Fish that people in Bardhaman still bring up. On the first evening Thakuma sat in a chair at the centre of it all, in a cream sari with a red border, and received her guests like a small, pleased queen. Mohona was happy. Bulu carried something. Nobody remembers what.

Then the guests went home, and the instalments began.

The first year: Subir

He had always meant to stop working at sixty. He had a plan for it, involving a harmonium he did not yet own.

Some time in the first year he did the subtraction on the back of a delivery challan. The loan would end when he was sixty-three. He went to the owner of the press and asked, lightly, as though it were the owner’s convenience he had in mind, whether there might be contract work for a man after retirement. There might.

He told Mitali he would only get bored at home anyway. She said yes, probably, and did not look up from the rice.

The second year: Arko

Arko had a place on a hotel-management diploma in Kolkata. He had the letter. He kept it in the steel almirah, in the folder with the birth certificates, which is where that family put things that were certain.

“Next year,” said Subir.

“Of course,” said Arko, and took a job at a mobile recharge counter near the station. He was cheerful about it, in a way that was harder to look at than sulking would have been. He never once mentioned the fish.

The third year: Mohona

Mohona found out from Thakuma, by accident, on an afternoon visit.

“Your father works too hard,” said Thakuma, “for a man who is still paying for his daughter’s wedding.”

“Paying?”

“Paid. I meant paid.” But she was eighty-three by then and no longer quick enough to take a word back.

Mohona had believed it was savings. She had believed “it is handled” meant that it had been handled. She came the next Sunday with her husband Ritwik and ₹1,50,000 from their own account, and put the cheque on the kitchen table, on the spot where the list had been.

Subir would not touch it. A father did not take money from his married daughter for her own wedding. He said this several times, in several ways.

“Then don’t take it from her,” said Mitali. “She has given it to me. Take it from me.”

The bank accepted a part-payment in month 30, for a charge of ₹3,000. And then came the real argument, which was not about pride at all.

₹1,50,000 comes off the loan. What should the relief be used for?

  • Keep the instalment and finish sooner

    Subir's choice. The loan ends 10 months early and saves ₹46,464 in interest. He wants it gone.

  • Keep the five years and lower the instalmentThe story follows this one

    Mitali's choice. The instalment falls to ₹12,319, which frees ₹5,883 a month now. It saves ₹26,497.

“Your way is ₹19,967 more expensive,” Subir told his wife. He had done the working twice.

“Yes,” said Mitali. “And Arko is twenty-four.”

There was no column for that. The instalment came down. In July, Arko left for Kolkata with a steel trunk and the letter from the almirah, which the college had agreed, after some correspondence, was still good.

The fifth year: Thakuma

The last instalment left the account on a Thursday. Subir had expected to feel something large. Mostly he felt hungry. Mitali made luchi.

That night he did one final sum, because he could not help it. On top of the ₹8,00,000 itself, the borrowing had cost them ₹2,80,651 in interest and charges. He divided that by the 330 guests beyond his rule. It came to ₹850 each.

₹850

for each of the 330 guests beyond the first 120. That is the cost of the borrowing alone, not of feeding them.

He considered Bulu. Was Bulu worth ₹850?

“He carried the bananas,” Subir said aloud, to nobody.

Thakuma was eighty-six now and spent her afternoons with the album. She turned the pages slowly and named everyone, including people Subir could not have named with a gun to his head. She said that the first evening had been the best day of her life. Better than her own wedding, at which she had been fourteen and frightened.

“Everyone came,” she said. “Everyone.”

She was right, and that is the awkward centre of this story. The day was worth having. It was also 60 months long.

Mohona asked him once, when it was all over, whether he would do it again.

He thought about it properly, the way he thought about a column that would not balance.

“The wedding, yes,” he said. “But I would read the second page.”

The other future

One hundred and twenty

In the other version Subir holds the line. The list stays at one sheet. Bulu is not invited. The press is not invited. The groom’s family is asked whether they might manage with fifty, a request that takes Subir three drafts to write and is received with a silence that has weather in it.

There is no loan. He retires at sixty and buys the harmonium. Arko goes to Kolkata the year he was meant to.

And his elder brother’s wife does not visit for two Pujas. A colleague at the press, whose son’s wedding Subir attended and ate at, stops keeping him a seat at lunch. Thakuma has a lovely evening, and afterwards asks, twice, whether Bulu is unwell. Nobody says anything to Subir directly. That is the method.

He saved ₹2,80,651 and five years. He paid in a currency the bank does not handle. Whether that was cheaper depends on what a seat at lunch is worth to a man, and that is not a figure he could have looked up beforehand.

Computed, not fiction

The assumptions behind the numbers

The amounts below were chosen by the writer to suit the story. Every other figure on this page was calculated from them by the tested engine when the page was built.

Personal loan
₹8,00,000 at 13% a year, fixed, for 60 months
Processing fee
1.5% of the loan
Subir's take-home pay
₹62,000 a month in year one, rising to ₹75,000 in year five
Part-payment
₹1,50,000 in month 30
Charge on part-payment
2% of the amount, as written in this fictional loan agreement
Guests
120 planned, 450 invited

What the calculation leaves out

  • What the wedding itself cost beyond the loan. Only the borrowed part is modelled.
  • Tax, insurance sold with the loan, and any late charges. Nothing in this story is paid late.
  • Gifts received, which in real weddings offset some of the cost and are not known here.

Illustration only. Not advice, and not a prediction for any real loan.

Change the numbers

The Bhattacharyas' loan is loaded, part-payment included. Switch between finishing sooner and lowering the instalment, and watch what each one saves.

Open this loan in the calculator

Run your own numbers Personal Loan EMI Calculator

Sources for the blue notes

Next story

Your Number Is Busy

Dev was six days late with one instalment. He did not get a reminder. His sister did, and his manager, and his old cricket coach, and a tailor in Model Town.